Talk About Marriage banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

I want a relationship. I want to be single. I...

8K views 64 replies 23 participants last post by  MrsHolland 
#1 ·
I can't make up my mind. I've been divorced for 2 years now - separated 4 years after discovering my wife's affair(s). We were married for 14 years. Her infidelity profoundly changed me as a person and changed how I view relationships - which I'm sure is fairly common.

After the breakup I jumped right into dating. I had more sexual partners in the 2 years post split than I did in my entire life before that combined. Not once did I develop any real feelings for any of these women (besides liking them). I don't know if that's because I just haven't found anyone I really connect with or because I'm incapable of it. I believe I have built a wall around me to protect myself - as I don't feel I can ever allow myself to be that vulnerable again. I've heard the "you're emotionally unavailable" thing more than once from the women I've dated.

I haven't had a "girlfriend" since August 2015. Since I ended that - I haven't been searching one out. I kinda gave up. I just don't feel anything. I have been sleeping with a woman since the breakup of the last relationship - we had hooked up before, things got too serious, I bailed. She approached me again and said she'd be cool with just being lovers. I was hesitant but agreed to try - we've been sleeping together for over a year and are great friends. She's awesome - but I do not love her or desire a relationship beyond what we have. She's cool with this. We discussed the other night how much we enjoy our freedom (she divorced her abusive husband). She has expressed to me she's happy with us being lovers and she really enjoys the "great sex". We also have great conversation. Frequency is every second weekend. I have not slept with anyone else since we've been doing it. I don't know if she has or not.

I waffle back and forth on wanting a girlfriend and not. I am enjoying the hell out of my freedom. I have my kids Friday-Monday, and during the weeknights I don't have them I am enjoying working on my hobbies and avocation. I'm never bored or really lonely at all. However, I know the one thing keeping me from pursuing a real relationship is that my sexual needs are being met. I'm very high drive, and if I wasn't sleeping with my lover, I'd be seeking it out, and that would lead to a relationship. I'm very lucky in that a I have this lover who is happy with the way things are.

However I keep thinking I'm supposed to be in a relationship. I see everyone around me in one. I see beautiful women and think "I want her to be my girlfriend!!". However I realize that's just lust.

Sometimes I think I really want a partner - but the truth of it is I am scared to death of a relationship. I have major trust issues which cause me to be emotionally unavailable, and I'm just not really willing to sacrifice my freedom, or give up a part of myself - which I feel I'd have to do - to have a relationship. I read the CWI forum, and see people in real life, and it just seems like the odds of a woman cheating are too high (men too I'm sure, but I'm not a woman, so not talking about that at the moment). Relationships seem like Russian Roulette to me. With more chambers loaded than not.

I recently signed up for Match and had a couple dates lined up - I just bailed on them and stopped messaging women. I had a date with a beautiful woman all set and all I had was anxiety about it - zero excitement. It never went down and I was relieved. WTF??

I'm 40 though and not getting younger. I worry about ...should I be with someone? Is that what you're supposed to do in life? Would I be willing to take the risk and give up my freedom for the right person - or is there no "right person" because I'm all f'ed up? Am I still damaged from the affair/divorce? Just not ready? Or is this the new me - and I'm one of those MGTOW? Is this the new reality - single forever and just hooking up to get my sexual needs met? Do I need to push myself out of my comfort zone, take the risk, give up my freedom and just take the plunge in hopes I fall in love and it's all worth it? Am I even capable of falling in love? Do I actually want a relationship but I'm just scared, or do I think I'm supposed to be in one but actually I'm totally happy being single?

Ugh. I'm really conflicted and somewhat confused. Anyone relate or have any insight for me?
 
See less See more
#4 ·
You say you're going to therapy because you're confused and you have a wall built up and you have no clue what you want out of life.

That's what a good therapist does- they help you figure yourself out.

In case you didn't realize it, most therapists are incompetant. If you've only gone to 3 you haven't gone to enough.

Come back and complain about the lack of good counseling after you've tried a dozen.
 
#8 ·
So she's lying? Why? And I don't appreciate the slag.

Back when we started out, she started to get serious. I put the brakes on and said I wasn't interested in this becoming serious - totally 100% honest. I ended it. She approached me a year and some later and said "I thought about it, and I don't know why I was pushing for a relationship - I don't want that either. Are you interested in just being lovers again?" I was hesitant but said sure. It's been over a year now, we've discussed it in detail since and she has expressed that she is happy with the arrangement. Don't need the guilt trip about that - seems that's your issue, not mine or hers.
 
#33 ·
I don't know if its common but I've been divorced for about 4 years as well and I'm still a mess.

I'm 53 and I don't know what I want. I wouldn't mind a FWB but haven't come a crossed that. I did OLD for a short while and didn't meet anyone I was interested in. I also stressed about dates and was relieved if they'd get canceled. I'm currently not dating at all and don't go out much. Part of the reason is my confidence and self esteem is still low because of XWW's cheating. I'm starting to see a therapist and sort out some of this stuff. Hopefully I will get past this and start living again. I keep thinking that time is running out and if I want to be with someone, I better get started. XWW didn't skip a beat. Her and poSOM broke up and she's been on to someone new for over a year.
 
#9 ·
Don't sweat it. If you meet someone you will know it. In the meantime, don't worry about what society expects of you or for that matter other posters on TAM. Live the life you want to live. Enjoy your life on your terms. Your life is no one else's so don't allow anyone else to attempt to manage it for you.
I am more or less in the same boat as you. Although I am older (55) and only 2 years out of my divorce. As far as I know there was no cheating, but there was betrayal all the same. Currently I am just randomly dating and have no clue if I want to get involved in a relationship. Like you I was changed by my divorce. All of my fantasies about how relationships are supposed to work blew up in my face. Now I have a somewhat jaded view of LTRs. So I guess I am stuck with short term relationships for the time being. Who knows, maybe one of them will last, but I am not going to force it.
BTW, get ready for the STD naysayers to come out in full force shortly.
 
#11 ·
Haha! Thanks, that makes sense. That's kinda how I feel - like I'm really enjoying myself for the most part. I'm really productive at work and in my free time - I'm never bored and as I said, I enjoy my solitude. I really don't get lonely. I love my time with my kids and when I'm on my own I'm accomplishing stuff that's important to me. The Online dating thing - I always end up backing away as it just seems..forced. If something happens, I think it maybe should happen organically. Like in the elevator at work the other day - this woman just starts a conversation with me. Totally attractive blonde and she was flirting. It was first thing in the morning and I was NOT on my game, smh. She walked away and only THEN did I think of witty banter and all this stuff to say. Guess I should be better prepped for that sort of thing. Hoping you're right on the "If you meet someone you will know it." One thing I've learned is you just can't force it or even go looking for it - it just doesn't seem to work that way.

STD naysayers?
 
#10 ·
OP, I would like to add that you are probably healthier mentally, than 90% of the population. In fact I would venture to guess that the vast majority of relationship problems arise from the NEED to be in a relationship. Many young people, jump into one because that is what is expected of them.
 
#14 ·
Thank you. I am MUCH happier and mentally (and physically) healthier than I was when I was married. I'm actually quite happy. I guess I just need to know it's OK to be OK with being single.

I feel the same way as you, all I can say is "I do not know" haha

Just relax, go with the flow, live your life, if love is meant your way, love will find you...

I am no help. Simply stating you are not the only one who feels as you do.

Oh yes, also, I have been divorced two years as well, after a 15 year marriage. Love is not easy to find. Wounds take long to heal. Nobody is the same.
 
#16 · (Edited)
it's coming up on a year since I officially moved out and ended my 8 year marriage. (the divorce is still ongoing) For almost a year before that, we were married in name only, and part of that time was an in house separation. He was on drugs. drinking heavily, abusive, and I found out afterwards, also having at the very least an EA, probably a PA.

I waffle back and forth like this all the time. I'd love to be in a relationship, but i really value my independence and alone time. I like being the captain of my own destiny, but being unattached and high drive is a not so fun at times. I also have some concerns about picking another cheater, or another controlling abusive man, or someone who (in the eventuality that they meet) won't treat my kids well. I also feel like I haven't met anyone I've clicked with.
I figure it's my new normal, and i'm trying to embrace it.
It may be unpleasant or lonely at times, but not nearly as unpleasant as my marriage was.

as far as having a FWB, I think you are correct that it has you in a holding pattern. Sexually sated enough to not pursue anything resembling a full relationship, and just barely lonely enough to feel that twinge when you are around lots of couples or an attractive woman. But even if it is preventing you from pursuing a relationship/love, is that a bad thing? If and when you are ready for something different, then you will move on. As long as both parties are consenting adults and aware of what it is, then I really don't see the problem.

you probably do need some counseling if you feel like:
"Relationships seem like Russian Roulette to me. With more chambers loaded than not." And the anxiety about dating. Concerns about choosing a similar bad person again are probably valid. However, anxiety so much that you feel relieved at a cancelled date seems unhealthy. But what do I know, i'm a homebody that often experiences relief at cancelled plans : )
 
#20 ·
This post is so on point. I'm sorry you went through such a terrible marriage - I'm glad you're free of what seems like a not good man. You and I sound very similar.

The "new normal" indeed. I really, really cherish my solitude and freedom. it's awesome.

And you're right about the FWB - it's a holding pattern for sure. But it's one I'm comfortable in. And the sex is dynamite. We have amazing chemistry - even the first time we did it, it was fireworks. And we have fantastic conversation. It's too bad I don't have deeper feelings for her.

And you know what - the anxiety about the date wasn't even so much about the woman herself, it is because, like you, I am SUCH a homebody. Usually after I force myself to go out I'm happy I did - but I am so content staying home and doing my thing. I do all my socializing at work. I'm relieved when plans are cancelled too - date or not. It's like George Costanza said: "I've never gone to a meeting where I actually wanted the other person to show up".
 
#18 ·
Moth, I'm in the same boat only I don't worry about what other people may or may not think. I think if you meet someone that's amazing you'll know it and decide you are ready for a relationship. Not knowing now just means you haven't found someone that you are ready to commit to. Enjoy the single life and your FWB; there is nothing wrong with either of those.
 
#19 ·
If you don't want or aren't ready for a relationship then don't have one. Who cares what you're "supposed to do" or what other people think you "should" do? Just be honest w/ your intentions (or lack thereof) and don't allow yourself to become "the other man". Sounds like you've already got a handle on that, though.

As for healing? Maybe you just need a bit more time and, if you rush it, it might not be authentic.

Either way, yes -- please be careful. After all, most people drive only a single vehicle... and it's usually the vehicle for which they're directly responsible for maintenance, etc.

Additionally, if you make a habit of riding around w/ people that tend to get in wrecks... well, you'll eventually wind up in a wreck yourself.
 
#21 ·
I may have been lucky as I found a good consoler my 2nd try.

I was in your spot after my wife died in 2002. So much of me was dedicated to her & our life. I too vacillated between being alone forever and seek someone out of loneliness.

My consoler help me realized I was putting too much pressure on myself. Short story I did what is called the 180 here. I worked on me and mostly tried to have fun. Re-found my life for me. I dated a bit & rode a crazy train for a few months and eventually I found a gal I could really be myself around.
 
#22 ·
That "someone you can be yourself around" is huge for me. I always feel like I have to put on a show or something...and I don't want to do that. Of course when you're first dating anyone you don;t want to be farting and stuff - but eventually you should be able to be yourself. I guess I'm still shaken from the marriage and there's a lot of fear there.

I think the biggest thing is I want whatever happens (if it happens) to happen organically. Problem is I hate going out so it'll have to be when I'm at work (it's a huge company) or at the grocery store or something.

Glad you found a lady you get to be yourself around!
 
#23 ·
I'm in the same boat as you moth, except I don't have a FWB like you do. But don't sweat it. Four years is not all that long after what you have been through. Just enjoy life as it is. You don't need to change anything. I think you just need to be the best person you can be, be content and happy in yourself, and someone who matches you will eventually come along.

People don't so much "find" each other as they usually accidentally "collide" with each other out of the blue... or at least that has been my experience. The deepest relationships I have had occurred when I wasn't really looking.

Quit sweating it. At least you have a FWB taking care of you...

Bastard... :mad:


:D
 
#26 ·
I will hit this subject on a side wall. The back wall is reserved for....................censored.

Listen, I do not think people change that much after passing the 25 year mark. You have been this way for a long time, admit it.

You say you are emotionally unavailable? I believe you and I believe this.

This may have contributed to the collapse of your marriage. Cheating by your EX was wrong and cannot be pinned on your hide. She did this. Not you. She should have gotten a divorce before looking for love elsewhere.

If you do eventually get serious, form a real LTR, an engagement and another marriage, you had better take a good look at yourself in the mirror.

I believe you are doing this, already.

Your EX needed to be validated by someone, if you did not "convincingly" step up, she had the excuse to cheat that all Waywards seek.

In reference to this Blog, Talk about Marriage, TAM, do not think that a large majority of relationships end up in cheating. The number of married women who cheat is low. Some reliable studies say 17 percent, some put it higher at 40 percent. These studies often ask this question: Have you ever cheated on a partner? This would include young person relationships, steady dating, and exclusive relationships.

These percentages gets rolled into Engagements and Marriages and drive the numbers higher.

Desperate people get advice here. They ARE NOT representative of the marriage state in the Western World.

Actual cheating in marriages are much lower. They are higher than we would like. I think the numbers are steadily rising.

You need to fine-tune your mate picker. Choose a lady that likes you "in spite of" your emotional un-availability. Your current hottie sounds nice. But I suspect she is using you for fun and sex...also. And she has other men at her disposal Not a problem, at this time.

No, you do not have to get in a relationship if you are not ready. If you meet the right women, you will have little control over your picker. It will keep you awake at night.....uh-huh!
 
#36 · (Edited)
Been like what for a long time? No, I wasn't emotionally unavailable in my marriage. I was open, committed, always faithful and loving. My ex wife got herself a lovely little cocaine habit and lived a whole other life that I didn't know about. "This may have contributed to the collapse of your marriage". Uhh, no. Cocaine, a lack of morals and self esteem, selfishness, entitlement and immaturity on my exww's part "contributed" to the collapse of my marriage. Was I a perfect husband? of course not. No such thing. And I never expected perfection from my ex. I was a good husband to her. And to this day she tells me that and expresses great regret. "It was the biggest mistake I ever made in my life and that hole in my heart will be there forever". She's said that in various different ways many times over, and to this day. I NEVER would have left my wife if it weren't for the cheating. She was an emotionally abusive basket case - but I would have stuck around until the bitter end - until she put another man's penis inside her. That gave me the ability to walk away from that toxic marriage with integrity.
 
#31 ·
There is nothing wrong with feeling this way. I am ending marriage #2. I was in a bad spot after the first, had a couple of relationships and got sucked in with the great sex and solid homelife with my current stbx. I am 40 also and I have been contemplating on where I want to go from here. Do I try to get one last big contract and hope that sets me up for life, or do I just retire and move on with my life. There is that comfort level that I fear will be gone forever. I had always thought I'd have the nice nuclear family, a house in the burbs, good times and happiness. I realize that ain't happening now, which is sad, bit also takes the pressure off. I am still new in the separation, so, it's not like I am looking for love now, but sometimes I feel like there is a void. Maybe it will be different when I am settled back into the life I want to make now. Honestly, if it weren't for my kids, an RV would sound great :)

There is no doing life right. There is no prize at the end. Nobody will care or remember. All you can do is try to make yourself happy. Just don't try to maintain a mold just for the sake of maintaining it. If it does strike, fear not.
 
#40 ·
I now find comfort in my solitude and singledom. I used to find comfort in my nuclear family. Now? I can't even look at old pictures of the kids from when we were together without feeling pain. Not pain from losing her or not being with her - that's a good thing. But the loss of my nuclear family. The children's loss of their family unit. The pain we all went through and the fact that my children are from a broken home, and that I was (we were) betrayed and lied to so badly. I look at pictures of those precious children and think of us waiting for her to come home - but she wouldn't, because she was out doing blow and screwing other men. That she could do that to her beautiful children...me? Whatever. I'm a big boy. I survived. But my trust is gone, and so is my faith in the idea that my monogamy will be reciprocated.

I like your advice though - and I'm sorry you're headed for another divorce.
 
#41 ·
I'm 40 though and not getting younger. I worry about ...should I be with someone? Is that what you're supposed to do in life? Would I be willing to take the risk and give up my freedom for the right person - or is there no "right person" because I'm all f'ed up? Am I still damaged from the affair/divorce? Just not ready? Or is this the new me - and I'm one of those MGTOW? Is this the new reality - single forever and just hooking up to get my sexual needs met? Do I need to push myself out of my comfort zone, take the risk, give up my freedom and just take the plunge in hopes I fall in love and it's all worth it? Am I even capable of falling in love? Do I actually want a relationship but I'm just scared, or do I think I'm supposed to be in one but actually I'm totally happy being single?
Why is the future so unsettling? You have it sounding like both your main and reserve canopy have deployed, failed, and there is nothing coming but ground?

It's the present that makes the difference... we are all a little damaged when an affair/divorce happens, being human causes that. As long as you are not harming someone as you work through your path, one can stay behind the clouds but eventually you will have to peek out as you pass through them and survey the landscape below hopefully before you enter into a new cloud of protection.

Years are like altitudes... you only have so much time before you come to an end of the journey. You really have to cutaway all those things that get in the way before you think about when your reserve is needed, but one who is mindful grows wings making the reserve (FWB) unnecessary.

Create your own updraft, a slower decent will aid you well... life is more width than length anyways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moth-into-flame
#44 ·
Good post, although I don't know that the FWB is a reserve...we truly enjoy each other's company and the sex is dynamite. We're both happy with how the relationship is. Will that last forever? Doubtful. One of us will find someone else, someone will decide it's just not enough...whatever. But for now, we're both enjoying it for what it is.
 
#45 ·
On a side note - I have a coffee date with a gal Thursday. I'm not going to bail this time. It's kinda cool - it's a social date as well as a potential business meeting - which actually takes a little of the pressure off. And it's just coffee instead of a full on dinner and drinks thing. We'll see what happens.
 
#47 ·
why are we some how expected to follow a certain set of guidelines or rules about is expected of us, or about the right prescription for happiness. That in not following them your a failure, or not happy. its time to throw away all the social morays around happiness and contentment and follow our own path regardless of what people say. we need to define our own journey, our definition of what it means to be happy, and if that happiness comes in the form of solitude than so be it. there is a sense of peace that comes with the tranquility of one's self-determination to pursue persoanl goals. because in the end when your resting in that box, there are no mulligans.
 
#56 ·
Or is this the new me - and I'm one of those MGTOW? Is this the new reality - single forever and just hooking up to get my sexual needs met?
Idk man, I guess it's all in the eye of the beholder. For many a dude, trapped in a sexless marriage with a nagging wife using him as a paycheck, your current situation would be HEAVEN to him.
 
#59 ·
Had a first date with a woman I met on ******* yesterday - just coffee. She's a child therapist. She was late, which stressed her out. It went well - lots of conversation. I couldn't tell if she was just nervous or if she's high-energy/uppity. She laughed a lot and got kinda loud a few times. Lol. We agreed to another date next week, this time drinks in the evening. Hopefully by the second date I'll know if there's chemistry. She texted me last night saying she had a great time and is looking forward to the next time. I was pretty chill and confident...I'm not really too fussed any more with it all. She's 7 years my junior, 2 kids same age as mine.

A bit apprehensive as I know if I pursue a relationship I'll need to end things with FWB - but I don't want to throw that away for something that will fizzle in short order. I guess that's selfish.

Oh well, at least I actually went out and did it this time.
 
#62 ·
A bit apprehensive as I know if I pursue a relationship I'll need to end things with FWB - but I don't want to throw that away for something that will fizzle in short order. I guess that's selfish.
Don't borrow trouble. You have made it clear that you don't have romantic feelings with your FWB and as long as it's clear that there is no commitment to monogamy, then you need to not worry about things that might not happen.

You've been on one date. That does not make a relationship.


Anyway, that's not why I jumped in here. I jumped in here because I get it. I don't want a relationship either. I don't want to share my bed, I don't want to clean up after someone, I don't want to watch shows I don't like, I don't want remind someone to put down the toilet seat. I am no mood for compromise. And apparently I am willing to forgo sex to keep my freedom. And it's funny, because I liked being married in many ways, but I know a lot of it was because I loved being in love. But now that I am not, I am not eager to do it again. The betrayal was too deep and in truth, you just can't tell. You can't guarantee that a relationship will last forever and that you both will work on it. And so it's a lot of emotion and sacrifice with an uncertain outcome. Or maybe I feel that way because I came out the loser. Or maybe two years is not enough time, I don't know. I just know I feel the same way you do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
Top