Quote:
Originally Posted by Drover My wife was recently diagnosed as Bipolar Disorder I after a severe manic episode with major psychotic break. Our marriage has not been good for quite some time. |
Drover, some of the dysfunctional behaviors you describe -- verbal abuse, blame-shifting, and irrational anger -- may be due to an issue more serious than bipolar-I. A recent study of nearly 35,000 American adults (pub. 2008) found that half of the bipolar-I sufferers also suffer from full-blown BPD (Borderline Personality Disorder). This implies there is a 50% chance your W also suffers from BPD. See Table 2 at
Prevalence, Correlates, Disability, and Comorbidity of DSM-IV Borderline Personality Disorder: Results from the Wave 2 National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions.
Quote:
|
She wanted me to be more dominant. The problem is that when I do it, she fights it.... Why is she acting that way when she wants this? [From your "Pants" thread.]
|
One possibility, as Halien suggests in your "Pants" thread, is that you are trying to control the wrong things. Perhaps you are. Another possibility -- indeed, a 50% probability if those study results are correct -- is that your W has strong BPD traits in addition to bipolar.
BPDers have such a weak, unstable self image that they yearn to live with a person having a strong personality. They need that person to stabilize and ground them, giving them a sense of direction. This is why BPDers typically hate to be alone. As soon as they find a strong person like that, they are in heaven for 3 to 6 months, believing they have found the perfect soul mate. Yet, as soon as their infatuation evaporates, they become resentful, feeling like the mate is trying to control them.
Hence, when a woman has a weak sense of who she is, she will desperately crave to be around a strong man but, after several months, she will feel like she is losing her own identity in his strong personality. She thus will complain about "being controlled."
My exW was that way. If I bought her a present, she resented the fact that I picked it out. If I asked her ahead of time what sort of gift she would like me to buy, she felt that I was the one deciding
when it could be bought. And, if we agreed on her having her own separate budget for such frills, she felt that I somehow had been the one to dictate the budget. As I learned, the result is a lose-lose situation because a BPDer will be unhappy if you do not help to ground and center her, and she will be equally unhappy if you do.
Quote:
|
It doesn't matter what the decision is she wants to turn it into a big drama and argue it to death, and will probably get nasty about it if she doesn't get her way.
|
If she has strong BPD traits, this behavior is typical. BPDers (i.e., those with strong traits) lack the ability to control their emotions and therefore often experience intense feelings. Over the years, they become so used to this that they get bored easily when the intensity is missing. They therefore generally have little interest in finding solutions. Instead, they usually only want to create drama.
Another reason for the drama is to push the spouse away when they are feeling suffocated and controlled by the intimacy. This is why they tend to create fights -- over absolutely nothing -- immediately following a great weekend or intimate evening spent together.
Quote:
|
Any thoughts/ideas how to figure out what she really wants vs. what was manic nuttiness?
|
Drover, I suggest you see a clinical psychologist -- for a visit or two by yourself -- to obtain a candid professional opinion on what it is you are dealing with. Certainly, I don't know whether your W has most BPD traits at a strong level. Moreover, only a professional can diagnose BPD. I nonetheless believe you can spot the red flags if you take time to read about them. There is nothing subtle about traits such as verbal abuse and temper tantrums.
An easy place to start is my description of such traits in Maybe's thread at
My list of hell!. If that discussion rings a bell, I would be glad to discuss it with you and point you to good online resources. Take care, Drover.